Last Call for the American Airlines Aviator Red card?

Last week an article by CNBC indicated that Citigroup was in heavy negotiations with American Airlines to be the exclusive card issuer for American Airlines credit cards. These negotiations are immensely important for American Airlines because the revenue that comes from airline loyalty programs are now a huge portion of their income. It’s become so important, in fact, that it’s sometimes joked that airlines are credit card companies that fly planes. According to Delta CEO Ed Bastian, nearly 1% of the entire US economy is charged to Delta credit cards. The revenue from selling loyalty points to banks is a multi-billion dollar industry for airlines, and its a revenue stream they take very seriously.

American Airlines is in a strange situation because they have cobranded credit cards issued by two different banks. There are four credit cards issued by Citigroup which include three personal credit cards and one business card. Barclays technically has two personal American Airlines cards, but one is only available through upgrade, the AAdvantage Aviator Silver. The only Barclays American Airlines card with a current sign up bonus is the AAdvantage Aviator Red.

The fact that American Airlines has two banks issuing their credit cards is because of an American Airlines merger with US Airways over a decade ago. US Airways had a relationship with Barclays and after the merger US Airways credit cards issued by Barclays became American Airlines cards. American Airlines kept that relationship going, even as people began to forget about US Airways.

It makes sense for American Airlines and Citigroup to form an exclusive relationship. It would make the AAdvantage program more straightforward by reducing the complexity of having multiple card issuers. In the end, I think it’s highly likely that American Airlines will end their relationship with Barclays and form an exclusive relationship with Citigroup.

AAdvantage Aviator Red Card

If Barclays is going to get dropped from the AAdvantage program, it’s safe to say the Barclays AAdvantage Aviator Red card is going to go away. In some respects, good riddance, it’s not a very interesting card. It earns 2 miles per dollar spent on American Airlines purchases and 1 mile on everything else. You do get a free checked bag and preferred boarding but the annual fee is $99.

The thing that does make it interesting is that the signup bonus is incredibly easy to earn. Right now, there is a 70,000 mile signup bonus available through Frequent Miler’s website. What is the spending requirement? Signup and use it once. Literally, pay the $99 annual fee, activate the card and buy a pack of gum using the credit card and 70,000 AAdvantage miles are yours for the taking.

70,000 AAdvantage miles is a pretty decent haul. We took recently our family of four to Costa Rica from our small regional airport during Spring Break for a total of 120,000 AAdvantage miles and around $340 in taxes. Also, I have noticed, anecdotally, that flights out of smaller airports that are serviced by American Airlines don’t pay significantly higher amounts of points than flights out of larger airports. That it is definitely not the case for United Airlines, for example.

In addition, I’ve been eyeballing some deals to Portugal for spring break that are running around 22,500 AAdvantage miles one way per person. Having an extra 70,000 miles would top off our accounts enough to book the flights there, even though it wouldn’t be enough to get home.

Fear of Missing Out

I think that this is the last chance I have of taking advantage of one of the biggest no-brainers in points and miles. It’s legitimately buying 70,000 miles for $99. It’s not the best signup bonus the card has offered. Jenn got this card about a year ago when it offered 60,000 points for one charge and 15,000 for an authorized user and an additional charge to the authorized user card. However, it is definitely a solid deal, and waiting for a better deal at this point could mean that I miss out completely.

In the middle of writing this post, I actually did apply for this card and was approved. That’s fantastic and I will happily take my shiny new 70,000 miles from American Airlines. As a matter of fact, after I was approved, my daughter walked downstairs and I convinced her to apply for it as well and she was approved.

In all fairness, when I told her there was an annual fee she balked, but I told her if she would use her miles to pay for her ticket to Portugal, I would pay for her annual fee and she jumped on it.

Potentially Good News From the Exclusive Deal with Citigroup

Knowing that Barclays will likely be cut out of the American Airlines credit card business, it means that there will be less choices, and less available signup bonuses in the future. Still, it does raise the possibility of American Airlines becoming a transfer partner for Citi Thank You points.

American Airlines currently doesn’t have a transfer partner. Most major airlines have transfer partners, with Delta Airlines being a partner from American Express Membership Rewards points and United Airlines and Southwest Airlines being partners from Chase Ultimate Reward points. American Airlines was briefly a transfer partner of Citi Thank You points a few years ago, and was a transfer partner of Bilt Rewards very recently. A few months ago Bilt Rewards and American Airlines ended that partnership, and maybe that has to do with their negotiations with Citigroup.

With no current transfer partner, and with American Airlines negotiating a deal with Citigroup, there is a fairly good possibility that Citi Thank You points will become transferable to American Airlines. If that becomes a reality, I will definitely be attempting to earn more Citi Thank You points, because I find a lot of value in American Airlines miles.

In the end, I hope the changes that American Airlines makes to their credit card business with Citigroup works out to be beneficial to both them and their cardholders. Knowing how important that loyalty points are to the business of airlines puts a lot of pressure on them to have a good and profitable loyalty program. In the meantime, I need to figure out how I’m going to use these shiny new American Airlines miles.

Points Check December 2023

That’s a wrap for 2023 and it was a great year for us. We went on our first international trip as a family and primarily used points and miles that we earned in 2022 to book those trips. Jenn and I were able to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary in Cabo San Lucas, and the whole family took a pretty epic trip to Europe where we visited Zurich, Munich, Venice, Rome and Stockholm over two weeks. The cost savings from using those points and miles made those great trips possible for us.

We also booked a couple of trips for next year using points primarily earned in 2023. Jenn will be going on a girls trip to Playa Del Carmen with her mom and her sister. We have also booked a spring break trip with the kids to Costa Rica. I’m also looking into a couple of other trips for 2024, so I imagine we will be pretty busy.

Besides that, our points and miles balances grew dramatically in 2023, which should allow us a better flexibility when booking future trips.

Those AAdvantage Miles Were Gone Before We Knew it

We’ve obviously continued to earn miles on signup bonuses and December was no different. This month, Jenn earned a 75,000 point bonus on her AAdvantage Aviator Red card. This might be the easiest bonus in the points and miles world since she earned 60,000 AAdvantage miles simply by making one purchase and another 15,000 miles by naming our son as an authorized user and making a purchase on the authorized user card (I don’t get why Barclays does this, but it’s practically a free 75,000 AAdvantage mile bonus for next to no spend)

Those AAdvantage miles didn’t sit in her account very long though because we immediately used them to book those flights to Costa Rica. We were able to get 4 roundtrip tickets to Guanacaste from Moline on American Airlines for only 120,000 AAdvantage Miles and $336 which I thought was a pretty good deal. Both there and back we have an overnight layover, so we used 17,500 Marriott Bonvoy points for a hotel in Chicago on the way there and a Category 1-4 Hyatt certificate for a hotel stay at Dallas Fort Worth Airport on the way back.

Product Changing an Old Unused Citi Card

I product changed an old Citi Thank You Preferred card that I never used for a Citi Custom Cash. I couldn’t cancel the old card because it was my oldest credit card and canceling it would’ve negatively affected my credit score. The best bonus category was 2x on dining and I already have a Citi Premier that gets 3x on dining so it never got used. By switching to the Custom Cash card, I can earn 5x on by biggest spending category each month up to $500 in spending. I just need to remember to use it for just one category each month, and I failed on that for the first month. The product change process was extremely simple, I just called up Citibank and told them what I wanted. They switched it in just a matter of minutes and the cards arrived in about a week.

On to the Point check!

Our spending in December was pretty high, mainly because of Christmas, but there was also a tuition payment thrown in there. But the main amount of spending towards a bonus was on Jenn’s Citibusiness AAdvantage Platinum card, where she spent a little less than $3,500 and earned a little more than 3,600 AAdvantage miles.

Card UsedSpendPoints EarnedPoint ValuePoints Per $Return on Spend
Citi AAdvantage$1,1561,325$19.881.11.7%
Chase Ink Cash$5182,570$52.695.010.2%
World of Hyatt$3521,759$29.905.08.5%
United Business$351351$5.091.01.45%
Citi Custom Cash$305869$15.642.85.3%
Citi Premier$291694$12.492.44.3%
Wyndham Business Earner$113903$1.611.01.5%
Total$3,0998,540$147.032.84.7%

I’m still trying to dial in our non-bonus spending in the chart above, but made a couple of mistakes. First mistake was continuing to spend on my Citi AAdvantage Business Platinum Card after earning my bonus on it, since it’s a bad earning card. The second mistake was not just choosing a category for my Custom Cash card and sticking with it. The United Business card looks like a poor choice, but Jenn was getting cash back on groceries on that card, so it’s fine. Either way we finished with a return of about 4.7% on spending, and I would like that number to be consistently over 5%.

So with the Costa Rica redemption, the bonus and other earnings, we finished the month with 291,600 Chase Ultimate Reward Points, 88,400 Capital One miles, 35,900 AAdvantage miles, 31,600 Citi Thank You points, 30,900 Marriott Bonvoy points, 24,900 United miles, 15,100 Delta Skymiles, 5,500 Hyatt points, and $646 in cash back. Using the Points Guy valuations, we finished the month with $10,300 in points and miles, not too bad.

Points Check October 2023

October was a pretty dull month for us as far as accumulating points. Jenn signed up for a credit card and I continued to work toward a sign-up bonus but we didn’t manage to earn any sign-up bonuses. Our point value total inched back over the $10K threshold. That $10K threshold is pretty important to me because I believe that is where we can begin to really make good choices about how to spend those points without be subjected to using just one program or a couple of programs. The fact that more than 75% of that is in transferable points means that we really have a lot of different ways to take advantage of a lot of different programs.

Being Gimpy and a Change of Plans

We had booked a hotel in Madison with the expectation of participating in the Madison Marathon, but Jenn and I both had nagging injuries and that meant that we really were having a difficult time keeping our training up. We basically decided to switch our plans to go to Des Moines on the same weekend instead, because if we weren’t going to participate in the Madison Marathon, then I sure as hell was going to avoid the crowds associated with it. Because of that we had a change in hotel, we still used a Marriott certificate, but the second night was booked on points so there was a slight decrease in the cost of the new hotel, so we got about a thousand Bonvoy points back.

Another American Airlines Card

Jenn applied for the American Airlines Aviator Red card from Barclays. It is a personal card that at the time of application was offering a sign up bonus of 60K AAdvantage Miles when the $99 annual fee is paid and 1 purchase is made. An additional 15K AAdvantage Miles are earned when an authorized user makes 1 purchase.

The card earns 1 mile per dollar on everything except American Airlines purchases which earns 2 miles per dollar. It offers a companion ticket (domestic economy flight with $99 fee) if you spend $20,000 on the card in a year. It does offer a free checked bag, 25% off on inflight purchases and an annual $25 wifi credit on American Airlines flights.

None of that is too exciting and I definitely have no intention of spending $20K on a card that earns 1x just to earn a domestic companion ticket. This is a card that is pretty much only good for a quick charge to earn the sign up bonus, although the checked bags, wifi credit and discount on inflight purchases might be a good reason to use it when flying American Airlines. I would imagine that we will be canceling this card before we pay a second annual fee on it.

Costa Rica for Spring Break?

We have normally done spring break trips every year with the exception of last year. This was the first time that we considered flying for Spring Break. Before we got into points and miles, our trips usually involved us driving to the Gulf Coast and renting an Airbnb for a week and then driving back. Those trips generally meant 30 hours round trip in the car and an overpriced Airbnb. This time its a little different with points and we have a lot more options when booking airfare with points.

The problem with this seems to be that a spring break trip is probably going to have to be Tuesday to Tuesday because award tickets prices on the weekend during Spring Break are crazy high. Sorry, I’m not going to spend 80K miles round trip per ticket to go hang out with drunk college students in Cancun. But 30K-40K miles round trip to hang out in the jungle in Costa Rica, and my son misses two days of school? Maybe?

After talking about this with Jenn for a little while, Jenn was looking through Airbnb’s site and found a modern 3 bedroom house in coffee country within an Uber ride from the airport for $75 per night with a 4.99 rating. Nothing else in the area compared on price and quality, so she snatched it up before it disappeared, with the knowledge that its fully cancelable if we can’t make the flights work. I would prefer to book the flights first then the airfare, but with it being fully cancelable, I’m not worried about it.

Anyway, on to the Point Check!

Card UsedSpendPoints EarnedPoint ValuePoints Per $Return on Spend
Chase Ink Cash$5692,823$57.875.010.2%
US Bank Signature$5041008$10.802.02.0%
Capital One Venture$461955$17.672.13.8%
Chase Ink Unlimited$338507$10.391.53.1%
Wyndham Business Earner$1601,279$26.228.08.8%
Citi Premier$176444$7.992.54.5%
Chase Sapphire$151203$2.231.32.8%
Totals$2,3597,219$122.383.15.2%

So, looking at the chart above, I’m pretty happy. We spent a little less than $2,400 on credit cards where we weren’t trying to get a sign-up bonus and earned 5.2% back on that spending. That’s pretty good, I’ll be happy with any month we can get more than 5% back on non-signup bonus spending. This is a reminder to me to move spending off of the Chase Ink Unlimited and the US Bank Signature, because I’m pretty sure I can do better elsewhere. If I can’t find a bonus category for that spending, it should, at minimum be moved to the Capital One Venture card because it earns 2x on everything and the points are worth 1.85 cents per point, meaning that its a minimum 3.7% back.

Aside from that, I spent almost $2,300 on my Citibusiness AAdvantage Platinum Select Card, earning just shy of 2,500 points. That is a frustratingly low number of points to earn on that kind of spend but it’s okay when I’m trying to earn a sign-up bonus. It is a reminder to never use that card on anything besides with American Airlines, once the spending is completed.

At the end of the month, this leaves us with 285,800 Ultimate Rewards points, 86,400 Capital One Venture miles, 50,600 Marriott Bonvoy points, 27,500 Citi Thank You points, 24,600 United miles, 15,000 Delta Skymiles, 9,000 American Airlines miles, 3,700 Wyndham points and 1,600 Hyatt points as well as $974 in cash back. Using the valuations published by The Points Guy, this is all worth around $10,100.