It’s getting colder and darker and I’m beginning to prepare myself for the long cold winter ahead. Every year, I keep thinking, there’s no way I have to go through another one of these winters is there? But, alas, once again I haven’t become independently wealthy and moved to the Maldives, so I’m stuck in the Midwest for another cold, cold winter.
Luckily, we have planned a mid-January respite, a short trip to Puerto Vallarta to soak in a little sun, heat and avoid the cold winter for a little while. Weirdly, I haven’t thought much about that trip. We’re staying in an all-inclusive resort and that took a lot of the complexity out of the trip. I do need to come up with some things for us to do while we’re there, but knowing we can just show up and relax, does make it easier.

Rebooking
Aside from that, we got a little further on our plans for the trip to Europe next summer. Originally, we had booked a July 4th flight from Chicago to Paris using American Airlines points. The problem was that getting a reasonably inexpensive flight home was a struggle. I was able to find a flight home from Barcelona, but the time period didn’t work. Because of that, I canceled the Chicago to Paris flight, and booked the Barcelona to Chicago flight.
There were a ton of inexpensive available flights going to Europe, so we found one that worked that was from Chicago to Amsterdam a couple weeks before the Barcelona to Chicago flight. So, as a result, we have a flight to Amsterdam, and we’re leaving two weeks later out of Barcelona. We promised Alex a stop in Helsinki, so we just have to figure out how we’re getting from Amsterdam to Barcelona through Helsinki. Always a challenge…
I canceled my Chicago to Paris flights and got a refund immediately, but didn’t quite have enough American Airlines miles to book six flights both ways. Total I needed to book twelve tickets, six each way. I booked two of the flights through Alaska Airlines Atmos for 35,000 Atmos miles and $26 each, for the flights from Chicago to Amsterdam. The rest I booked through American Airlines for 23,000 AAdvantage miles and $5.60 each. The flights from Barcelona to Chicago were 21,000 AAdvantage mile and $48 each.
I was a little short on AAdvantage miles so I did have to transfer 5,000 Citi Thank You points to get us enough miles to book these flights.
So… We messed up
In order to book the flights, I needed to use 70,000 Atmos points to book an American Airlines partner award. I didn’t think that was going to be necessary. That’s because Jenn and I had both signed up for the American Airlines Platinum Select card, which came with an 80,000 point bonus. We both fulfilled the required spend on the cards, and I received my bonus, but she did not. When I looked into why, I realized that she had already received a bonus on that card and we had forgotten.
Citibank has a 48 month rule for receiving bonuses, which means you cannot receive a new signup bonus on any card that you have already received a bonus on. I’m certain that she signed up for the first Platinum Select card within the last 48 months, so she wasn’t eligible. We had completely forgotten about that signup bonus.
This is something that almost everyone who gets into points and miles does eventually, but it still feels really stupid. Anyway, so instead of Jenn getting something like 86,000 points for her spend on that card, she only got around 6,000 AAdvantage miles. Now I keep saying that we messed up, but I’m sure Jenn has placed the blame for this error squarely on me.
To be Fair, Though…
Jenn defends herself from my slanders.
Yes that card was all David's fault...he is the keeper of the points and cards and therefore should have known that I already had that card. However, we were at the bar when I applied so I guess I will let it go this time, but what a bummer to not get those points! I expect a higher level of detail from him in the future...that is all, rant done.
Amex Blue Business Cash
Jenn got an offer for an American Express Blue Business Cash card that was $500 cash back after $5,000 in spend in 3 months. She applied for it and was accepted. We don’t go after cash back cards that often, because generally we find better use for points than cash, but in this case, the deal was pretty good. Besides that, while we were planning out our trip in Europe, I noticed we will probably need to buy some train tickets, and there’s no point system for that, so cash back will help with those expenses.
This card is actually really simple. It’s a 2% cash back everywhere card on up to $50,000 per year in purchases, any purchases over $50,000 is 1% cash back. There are no bonus categories, no real perks to speak of, and no annual fee.
On to the Points Check!
So typically, I want our return on spend on credit cards that we are not working on a signup bonus to be over 5%. We’ve had no problem doing that, especially this year, where the majority of our non-bonus spend has been on the Bilt Palladium card which is easy to get over 6% return on spend. Unfortunately, the mistake we made about the AAdvantage Platinum card means that spending we thought was going toward a bonus was not. Again, whoopsie?
| Card Used | Spend | Points Earned | Point Value | Points Per $ | Return on Spend |
| AAdvantage Platinum | $1,160 | 1,349 | $19.56 | 1.2 | 1.7% |
| Bilt Palladium | $708 | 2,734 | $60.15 | 3.9 | 8.0% |
| Ink Cash | $454 | 2,273 | $46.60 | 5.0 | 10.3% |
| Wyndham Business Earner | $378 | 1,890 | $10.40 | 5.0 | 3.3% |
| Blue Business Plus | $136 | 272 | $5.44 | 2.0 | 4.0% |
| Amex Gold | $89 | 95 | $1.90 | 1.1 | 2.1% |
| Total | $2,925 | 8,613 | $144.04 | 2.9 | 4.9% |
Aside from that, I spent over $2,100 on my AAdvantage Platinum card and received my 80,000 AAdvantage mile bonus as well as an additional 3,700 AAdvantage miles on that spend. We immediately turned around and used that on those flights to Europe, so they are gone. With all of the earning and spending of miles this month, we are left with:
- 250,800 IHG Points
- 219,400 Chase Ultimate Reward Points
- 112,600 Bilt Points
- 97,500 Amex Membership Rewards Points
- 86,600 Alaska/Hawaiian Airlines Atmos Miles
- 81,800 Avios
- 67,000 Wyndham Points
- 51,200 Marriott Bonvoy Points
- 10,300 Hyatt Points
- 8,100 Citi Thank You Points
- 6,600 American Airlines Miles
- 1,500 Delta Miles
- 700 United Miles
- $133 Cash Back
Altogether, these points and miles, according to the valuations published by The Points Guy, are worth a total of $14,300. That is way down from $18,000 just three months ago, but trip planning will do that to your point totals. We’re just going to keep earning points and planning out that graduation trip for Alex. It’s going to be a great one!